Saturday, 21 November 2026

Defeat And Focus Quickly On Tuesday Night

The vital win ahead of the international break seemed to take a little of the pressure off this one. Of course we wanted something out of the game, a point being viewed as satisfactory, but if we lost with a decent performance, repeating the determination and application of the Sheffield game, we wouldn’t feel that all was lost. Nobody was under any illusions about the size of the task with Wolves, after a sticky start, having won four and drawn two of their last six – although it seemed they would be missing one or two forwards, which might help our cause.

That fact did indeed work in our favour in what proved to be a very mixed game. In the first half we put the ball in the net but that was given offside and otherwise barely threatened, played tentatively, but limited them to just one real chance and at 0-0 were the happier at the break. Then a couple of moments of magic from their right-winger before the hour, both times exposing Bell, and we were two down. Everyone thought that was game over for the next 30 minutes, only for us to pull one back out of the blue and set up a more interesting finish than had seemed likely. It would have been an outrageous point to grab, but wasn’t to be, leaving us to wonder whether if we had been more adventurous before we would have lost more heavily or got something from the game.

There was considerable uncertainty over the team/squad and formation ahead of the game. Would Jones stick with those who had served him well last time around? Would any of the injured then be available? And would he make changes in light of the opposition? It proved to be as you were, with an unchanged team, presumably driven by the continued absence of Lloyd Jones. Can’t remember the last time we said no changes. It would mean a 4-2-3-1 with McNamara, Biden, Koumetio and Bell in front of Mannion, Coventry and Mwamba in front of them, then Campbell, Rankin-Costello and Alli, with Kelman up top. The only change on the bench was Grant being available again and replacing Herbert.

The first half was pretty much all Wolves, who were to rack up 68% possession and have eight shots, one on target, against zeroes for us (as the offside ‘goal’ didn’t count). We struggled to find any sort of out ball to get Campbell and Alli into the game, with Kelman ploughing a very hard furrow. Wolves moved fluidly until the final third, but for almost all of the half misfired when they got within sight of goal.

Our moment came on 27 minutes as a corner was cleared but sent back in as their defence was coming out. Bindon headed down and Rankin-Costello swept it home, but nobody was contesting the linesman’s flag. Against that, it wasn’t until 39 minutes that Wolves had a real chance, one they should have taken. A sweeping ball out to their right was met by the full-back almost on the goalline. He put it back into the mix but their guy shot badly over the bar from close range. And just a minute later Wolves broke quickly and someone took the ball pretty much from box to box, his shot forcing a good save to his left from Mannion.

At the break the game plan was working, they hadn’t scored. But you felt they would play better in the second half and that it would only take one. They did start the second half in a higher gear and a couple of dangerous balls flashed across our box, before on 50 minutes they took the lead. Mane on their right was found with a long ball and he advanced as Bell retreated, made the space and squared the ball and their forward got to it first and scored. Three minutes later it was a carbon copy, this time Mane outmuscling Bell in a race for the ball, repeated the low cross, and the chance was taken.

With still over 40 minutes to go everybody watching and on the pitch thought that was that. Wolves played within themselves but still threatened a third, we still couldn’t get our wide men into the action. On 64 minutes Mesic, Skipp and Carey came on for Bell, Mwamba and Rankin-Costello but it all seemed rather academic. On 72 minutes it was Grant and Godden for Campbell and Kelman.

A third for them still looked more likely, especially as by now we were giving the ball away trying to play across the back, with no movement up front to encourage a more adventurous ball out. Mannion had to stretch low to his left to keep one out and on 79 minutes it was almost three as a ball into the box saw their guy turn towards goal and clip the shot on the turn. Mannion was helpless, but it hit the underside of the bar and was cleared.

Then glory be, on 81 minutes suddenly we had a game on our hands. Grant took the ball forward and from distance shaped to shoot. It looked speculative, desperate even, but the shot was hit well and bounced in front of their keeper diving to his right. He could only parry it and Godden, the only player who was taking the chance on a follow up, was able to drive it into the net through his legs from a narrow angle.

Suddenly Wolves were faced with the risk of not winning and we, with nothing to lose, tried to get the ball forward. From a long throw Koumetio headed on and Godden was there, but this time couldn’t get the strike away. That was the closest we came, the final minutes only notable for Coventry going through rather wildly with studs showing, with some relief when the ref’s card proved to be yellow, then was on the end of a similar one with the same outcome. Four minutes of stoppage time failed to produce the equaliser that would have had us laughing well beyond the rest of the day.

I thought the back line played well, with McNamara doing a good job and Bindon and Koumetio dealing with most of what was thrown at them. But Bell must hate speedy, tricky wingers and in the game’s decisive few minutes was caught out twice. It wasn’t a game we will remember for long, but it makes Lincoln at home on Tuesday night pretty much a must-win event. Today, like Middlesbrough away, was not going to define our season, but Tuesday night at The Valley under the lights, as against Bolton, is a very different affair. This time the result has to be the right one.


Saturday, 7 November 2026

Glory Be We've Won!

Like Tuesday night, today was all about the result, to the point that another defeat and more Addicks would be wondering if Jones’ time was really would be up. On paper the task was tougher, with Sheffield Utd seeking to get into the play-off places on the back of three wins and a draw in their last four games. And with the team news we learnt of further injuries, which at the time lowered expectations a little.

We needn’t have worried, shouldn’t have doubted. The crowd stood up and played their (crucial) part, the players reacted with increased energy and more intelligent football, getting the ball forward more quickly. And we didn’t fold when Sheffield equalised in the first half. With 15 minutes to go it could still have gone either way, but then Alli, having far and away his best game for us, laid it on and Godden showed Mendonca-like technique to convert at the near post. Thanks to saves from Mannion we saw it through. Victory. Such a relief, an almost forgotten joy. So good that it seemed Jones was overcome and exited quickly. I hope he’s enjoying the time now.

After four changes for Norwich, five for Middlesbrough, six for Bolton, today we were back down to four – but with surprises, seemingly caused by injury. Chalobah and Ramsay we had assumed would be missing, but added to them would be Lloyd Jones, Grant and Leaburn, while Knibbs dropped back to the bench. It looked like 4-2-3-1 again, possibly a 4-3-3, with Mannion retained and a back four of McNamara, Bindon, Koumetio and Bell. In midfield Coventry (who took the captain’s armband) was joined by Mwamba, while Rankin-Costello started, either in the middle of a more forward three, with Campbell and Alli, or in a three with effectively three up front, Kelman flanked by those two. With no Leaburn and Mbick not making the squad, the only outright forward on the bench was Godden. The subs included Nkeng and academy winger Hebert. For a match we needed to win, the news of further unexpected injuries didn’t exactly lift the mood ahead of the start.

Contrary to recent experience we almost went behind early on as an innocuous ball into our box dropped for their guy, only for Mannion to save well. But after a mixed opening spell, just after Rankin-Costello had played in TC very well and his cross nearly found Kelman, we took the lead. There seemed no real threat as Alli picked up the ball on the right, still some way out, but after a touch or two to cut inside he let loose a vicious shot which bounced and skidded off the turf and found the sweet spot just inside the post. Their keeper will be unhappy at being beaten from distance at his near post, but that mattered not at all.

And we came very close to extending that lead. On 16 minutes Bell and Campbell worked it well on the left and the latter sent in a good cross. It beat Kelman and his marker and went on to Mwamba arriving behind. Perhaps he didn’t expect it to reach him, but he failed to make a decent contact and put the ball into the net from close range. Then just after Rankin-Costello turned in the box and appeared to be pulled down by a defender going to ground. He appealed but the ref gave nothing. Merits seeing it again, but you’d say at the least you’ve seen them given.

Instead on 24 minutes it was all square. Alli conceded a foul on their left and the delivery of the free-kick was dangerous. Mannion punched out but didn’t get much distance on the ball. Unluckily for us it went straight to their forward and he nodded it back into an empty net. Truly hard lines and for a little while you felt, oh no, not again.

However, heads didn’t drop and we held our own for the rest of the first half. Mannion did miss a corner but was able to grab the ball from behind him as the header goalwards was weak. And we did pick up a collection of yellow cards, with McNamara quickly followed by Bindon and Mwamba. With a Sheffield player also picking one up, for a pull back on Campbell (who may or may not have been offside) and some of the challenges looking feisty, you doubted both teams would end with a full contingent.

A TC curler went wide and it was level at the break. The stats then showed 53% possession for us, with five attempts on goal, one on target, against five and three for them. We were still very much in the game, playing some decent stuff and competing, but there were concerns that they might get another, probably from a set piece. The nagging doubts were coming back.

There was an unfortunate start to the second half, as Sheffield made a change at full-back and the guy lasted less than two minutes before collapsing and being stretchered off (hopefully not too serious). He was in turn replaced by a centre-back, which suggested TC might be able to beat him for pace but also added to Sheffield’s arial presence from set pieces.

There was nothing much in it. The ref (and his assistants) failed to spot a blatant deliberate Sheffield handball to stop a dangerous through ball. But we were by now struggling to make things happen in their half and Jones made the first changes on 63 minutes. Knibbs and Carey came on for Rankin-Costello and Mwamba (both on yellows) to renew the drive and the game became rather more open. On 74 minutes after a decent spell of Charlton pressure Kelman scuffed a shot and that was his last contribution as he was replaced by Godden.

It took Godden just a few minutes to score the decisive goal. Good play again worked the ball out right to Alli. He took it into the area and wrongfooted his marker, making just enough space to get the cross in from a tight angle. The ball was behind Godden, there were three or four defenders around, but nobody as alert to the situation as him. He hit it on the turn and found the net with their keeper rooted to the spot. Godden again indeed.

Not surprisingly that electrified The Valley, but there were still 12 minutes on the clock and we knew there would be a fair chunk of stoppage time, given the early injury. And not surprisingly the later chances went to Sheffield as they had no option but to pile forward, with us nearly catching them on the break a few times.

Strangely the ref gave them another free-kick outside the box and Phillips curled one around the wall only for Mannion to turn it behind. Another move ended with a shot from the edge of the area that was central enough for Mannion to deal with. Skipp came on for TC to try to tie things up, but Sheffield had enough height and trickery out wide to still cause us problems. And our hearts were nearly broken seven minutes into added time as a ball from their right was played in and met by their guy. He swept it goalward but Mannion managed to get a hand to it to turn it around for a corner. Soon after we had the relief of the final whistle.

Nobody knows how important the win will turn out to be. But there were enough positive messages sent. The players ran their socks off for Jones, we got the win, to end any thoughts of his imminent exit, and the crowd gave it all they could to push us over the line. If it was like that every week football would be a simple game and a source of endless pleasure. But then again the sheer joy of ending such a long winless run will see us through the international break. Jones might be back on what for him serves as an even keel by the time that’s over.


Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Spirit Of November (2012) Needed For Saturday

If you can have a ‘must-win’ just 13 games into the season this was one. 10-game winless run, three consecutive defeats, 10 goals conceded in four games. And against a newly-promoted team on the same number of points, one which had lost its previous two and themselves averaging letting in two a game. We knew they would be no mugs; they won at Wolves after all. But with no disrespect to them they are among the favourites for the drop and the onus was on us to show greater quality. But if Boro was more about the performance, this one would be about the result, nothing else.

Instead, as against Watford, we committed the sin of letting them score first, in this case putting an end to what had been another quite bright start. That gave Bolton something to hold onto, enabling them to focus on getting everyone behind the ball and denying us space – although in the second half playing on the break as we through caution to the wind they looked more likely to add to their lead than us to score. It was a situation which called for precision and playing to a plan, accepting that we couldn’t play through them. Instead, after Leaburn came on at the break and had a positive impact, we threw on bodies in a strange fashion, creating confusion in our ranks, not theirs, and failed to deliver the ball into good areas (our crossing was appalling). We had a few chances to equalise but they went just wide and, once again, looked a sorry bunch at the final whistle.

Ahead of the game it was anyone’s guess what formation and team/squad Jones would opt for. After all, we had four changes for Norwich then five for Middlesbrough. And the number did keep rising as this time there were six. In goal Mannion came in for Okonkwu, while a reversion to a back four (and the 4-2-3-1 set-up) saw McNamara and Bell as full-back either side of Jones and Koumetio, with Binden and Mesik the defensive subs, with Ramsay presumably not available after his injury on Saturday. In midfield Chalobah came back into start and Coventry returned too, replacing Skipp and Rankin-Costello, with Knibbs in the centre of the three, Campbell and Grant both returning on either side. Along with Rankin-Costello and Skip, Carey and Alli were on the bench. Kelman would be lone striker, with Leaburn on the bench, along with Godden, a very welcome return. It looked like a return to Plan A, but would it prove that way on the pitch?

In the early stages it seemed it might. It was scrappy from both sides, but in the first 15 minutes we had the better of things and might have scored. First Kelman laid it off for Campbell and his cross to the far post found McNamara of all people in space but with not much to aim at. He effort was saved, but it gave us hope. Then Grant played a good through ball for Kelman to run on to, but he was outpaced/outmuscled by the defender. Then a ball was knocked back into the box and Kelman put it in the net, but he was clearly offside.

Then we went behind, to a horrible goal. We had everyone up front for a set piece and when the ball was cleared had Chalobah and Coventry as the last line of defence. All seemed OK as Chalobah won the ball, but he then seemed caught in two minds, whether to tap it back for Coventry or knock it all the way back to Mannion. The end result was in between and Coventry, caught flat-footed, was never going to catch their forward. It was just a matter of whether he would beat Mannion, which he did with ease.

And the whole game changed in that moment (of course we might have gone on to lose anyway). What confidence there was drained away. We made strange choices: TC skinned his opponent for pace and, although nothing came of it, you thought ‘go on, do it again, the guy will be scared’. Instead of that he and Grant switched sides. Knibbs went in late with his studs up and took a yellow (VAR might have interpreted it as meriting a red), Bell and Koumetio had to make desperate tackles as Bolton threatened, and right at the end we almost gave them another gift as we gave the ball away from our goalline.

At the break the stats showed 49% possession for us with five attempts on goal and two on target (the one from McNamara, can’t remember the other) against four and just the one (the goal) from them. We needed something to gee the crowd, attacking the Covered End, to lift the spirits and put Bolton under pressure.

It seemed we got that as Leaburn came on for Chalobah (later confirmed as a repeat of his injury, not tactical, which means that he returned, played 59 minutes, gifted the opposition two goals, and is now back on the treatment table). Of course it was a risk, with Knibbs dropping deeper to cover, making it a sort of 4-4-2 (I guess). And Leaburn started running down everything, putting in challenges and showing the sort of endeavour we would need to break them down.

We did as a result push them back, although they were reasonably content to surrender possession and play on the break – to reasonable effect, they might easily have scored again. They had the lead. Leaburn played in McNamara and his decent low cross was almost converted, then Leaburn was unable to get on the end of a cross but was appealing for a penalty for handball. Kelman was played in on the right and his low cross was cut out. And just before the hour Campbell delivered a good cross from the left and it was met well by Kelman, only for his header to go just wide of the post with their keeper beaten.

That was Kelman’s final contribution as he was withdrawn for Godden in what looked like a planned timing but appeared strange as the guy had just almost scored. No matter. Just after Knibbs played the ball back for Coventry but his decent strike from outside the box went wide. Then on 66 minutes we got a break as Grant’s miscontrol in the box ended with the defender knocking the ball back to their keeper, who opted to pick it up – then try to pretend he hadn’t. An indirect free kick on the edge of the six-yard box. Not easy to score though and predictably Bolton players were almost on Knibbs after Grant touched the ball to him and the shot was blocked.

On 76 minutes, as we seemed to be running out of steam, Jones brought on Rankin-Costello and Alli for Knibbs and McNamara. That meant we had Campbell, Alli, Leaburn and Godden to hopefully provide and finish. Instead the numbers seemed to compress the space in and around the box even more as Bolton sat tight, while set-piece deliveries continued to be poor (corners not clearing the near post, where we had nobody). On 83 minutes Carey replaced Grant, his only material contribution was to put in a corner which went behind for a goal-kick.

There was one final moment, in the six minutes of stoppage time. TC managed to cut inside to good effect and his curler ended up inches beyond the far post. On the night just not to be.

When you look at an account of the game it might read like a succession of Charlton chances which we somehow failed to convert. In truth, we managed no efforts on target in the second half (the Kelman header and Campbell’s shot notwithstanding) and most of the time Bolton were content. They ended up with 11 attempts on goal to our 14 and one more on target than us. The fact that we dominated possession in the second half (from 49% for the first half to 57% for the whole game) counted for nothing.

To say we needed a win last night was an understatement. I don’t know what the level up from that is, but come Saturday the need is immense, to change the atmosphere ahead of the international break, perhaps even to save Jones’ job. My only thought for that one is that we can’t keep making so many changes and expect cohesion – and a lack of cohesion leads to poor/safe passes and an inability to create and exploit space. Jones will have to make at least one for Sheff Utd as presumably Chalobah will be out, along perhaps with Ramsay. Depending on analysis of the opposition I’d be tempted to just replace Chalobah with Skipp, or Mwamba, and just hope that a good start leads to goals for us.

One thing is sure. The fans need to be absolutely behind the team, and Jones, ahead of and during the game. It can change games. Remember Cardiff at The Valley, also in November (2012). 0-2 down in the first 25 mins against a team chasing promotion and the players anticipating groans and boos. Instead ‘Chrissie Powell’s Red and White Army’ started echoing around the ground, inspiring Johnnie Jackson to take the game by the scruff of the neck. Back to 2-2 at half-time and then on to 5-2 up in the second (we’ll gloss over their two late goals to make it 5-4). Jones deserves that backing for the game, the team will have to show they are worthy of it.


Saturday, 31 October 2026

Nothing Gained At Boro

When one team is top of the league, at home, averaging over two goals a game, and boasts the division’s leading scorer, and the other is on a winless run of nine, can’t keep a clean sheet, and is coming off the back of two disappointing defeats, you might be tempted to watch this one from behind the sofa. Before the game Middlesbrough were around 1/4 on with the bookies, with 5/1 the draw and a Charlton win around 10/1, in a two-horse race. Even the CAST was joining in the black humour, pointing out that we were unbeaten since April with 3pm kick-offs. But this is football, we knew well enough what happened last season and, however unrealistic, there is always hope.

What we were really hoping for was a performance to be proud of, anything out of the game would be a (very welcome) bonus. Make Boro do something special to score. We didn’t really get that. We weren’t that bad, some decent play at times. But we let the opposition score soft goals and didn’t muster an attempt on goal, never a happy combination. As a contest the game was over when Boro scored their second just before half-time. We avoided humiliation in the second, but Boro won at something less than a canter.

Ahead of the game the formation and personnel were in doubt. Last season we unashamedly parked the bus, seldom got out of our half, and came away with the ultimate steal curtesy of Coady’s diversion of a long throw. But the win was also thanks to Middlesbrough having nobody to actually put the ball in the net. This time it would be different.

Nobody was surprised that Jones reverted to a back three/five (in a 5-3-2), with Bindon added to Jones and Koumetio, Ramsay and Bell as sort of wing-backs. Jones did follow that choice to its logical conclusion in that there was no starting place for either Campbell or Grant. Skipp returned to accompany Rankin-Costello with Knibbs rather than Carey in the more advanced position, and Leaburn and Kelman paired up front. It meant no real wide threat going forward but with Leaburn and Bidon added, when the two teams lined up it was apparent we had a clear height advantage. Could we make that pay?

For the second game in succession we almost took the lead in the first minute. Ball flicked on by Leaburn and Knibbs made ground down the right. His cross just evaded both Leaburn and Kelman. It was as close as we came all game. Middlesbrough showed plenty of style when breaking forward with the ball, their right-winger looking dangerous. Although we held our own in the early stages, on 11 minutes we were behind.

I blame the ref. We were on the attack and a ball out in the air was going to be won by us before a blatant shove in the back (this was to happen several times during the game). Nothing given and Middlesbrough broke quickly, switching play to their right. The winger played the ball inside and their guy took the shot. It didn’t look that dangerous, but it narrowly avoided Koumetio, who probably unsighted Okonkwu, who wrongfooted couldn’t get to the ball.

After that half-chances came and went, mostly for them, but on the half-hour we were still in the game and enjoyed a decent spell. Knibbs had a dangerous shot inside the box blocked then from a long throw Leaburn headed just wide. Then we had the absurdity of a rule as Ramsay was fouled badly outside our box. A yellow but could have been more. He carried on but soon went down and needed attention. Then he had to leave the field for a minute and while off the pitch Boro nearly scored from his area.

It looked as though at least if we made it to the break just one down it was still a contest. But on 43 minutes we went two down. Boro guy brings the ball forward and slides a ball between two central defenders, Jones and Bindon. Lankshear timed his run well (I assume so, no offside was given) and finished calmly. All far too easy, Jones and Bidon looking at each other and wondering which was to blame.

That changed the picture at half-time. The stats showed they had 63% possession, had seven attempts on goal with three on target against three and zero for us. We would have to score to get back into it – and not concede again. In the event we managed neither.

In truth the second half was a non-event. Boro seemed content with what they had, happy with the lead and likely to add to it without much trouble. We didn’t exactly go gung-ho and played as before, causing them no problems.

Ramsay couldn’t continue and was replaced by McNamara. We kept losing the ball in poor positions, enabling Boro to spring more breaks, but they failed to convert the chances that came their way. On 66 minutes Jones opted to bring on Campbell and Grant, with Rankin-Costello and Leaburn giving way. That meant still five at the back but now not much in central midfield, with Knibbs and Skipp. Whatever the formation was, TC was unable to make his presence count on the left flank and Grant failed to impact the game.

It stayed pretty low-key until on 79 minutes Jones made a second double-change. Chalobah and Alli came on for Skipp, who had a reasonable game, and Bindon, meaning a switch to four at the back. Any thoughts of that leading to a storming finish disappeared instantly. Chalobah under pressure outside the box slipped and was dispossessed by Lankshear. He had the time and space to pick his spot, planting the ball into the top corner. All that remained was to avoid a four or five-goal humiliation and we did at least manage that.

We know our season won’t be defined by today’s game. But Bolton and Sheff Utd at home up next are now vital. We have to win at least one of the two, to put an end to the winless run. It’s up to Jones and his people to look at the opposition and get the right formation and people to make it count. Just what that involves I’ve no idea. But as before it has to start with conceding no goals. We’ve now shipped 10 in the last four games.

Saturday, 24 October 2026

Now Officially A Crisis

A week ago we took on a team shipping bucketloads of goals, seemingly in disarray, questioning how long their manager would last etc and rolled over. We failed to score, played poorly, and ended up well beaten, in the process extending our own winless run to eight games. Today we welcomed Norwich, who had lost their last five games and stood just above the relegation spots. Surely not two weeks running, especially as it’s at The Valley.

Afraid so. You could say there were more positives to take from the game than Watford, that we bossed the first 20 minutes and took the lead (much as against Bristol City), that the game really should have come back to 2-2. All ifs and buts and for the second consecutive Saturday we trudged off the pitch in a despondent mood, now no win in nine, five points taken in those games. Officially a crisis.

Jones the Boss had hinted at changes ahead of the game and opted for four, plus a change in formation from the back 3/5 to the 4-2-3-1 set-up. In front of Okonkwo would be a back four of Ramsay, Jones, Koumetio and Edwards, with McNamara not in the squad and Bell, Bindon and Mesik on the bench. The defensive midfield pairing would be Coventry and Rankin-Costello, with Skipp out of the picture and Chalobah not yet risked, Mwamba being the back-up on the bench. The more forward three would be Campbell, Carey and Grant (with Campbell starting on the right side, Grant on the left), with Knibbs and Alli in reserve, while up front Leaburn moved to the bench, alongside Mbick, being replaced by Kelman.

It looked a more adventurous line up and that certainly seemed the case in the early part of the game, especially as the formation was more a 4-1-4-1 as Rankin-Costello operated to good effect in their half. We almost took the lead in the opening seconds as Norwich were sliced open by a ball through to TC in on goal. Wisely or not he opted to take a touch and that allowed their keeper to get closer and he was able to make the save. On four minutes Carey collected a loose ball out of defence and saw his shot blocked when there were others available in a good position.

Norwich looked decidedly shaky at the back and like a team that had lost five on the spin. However, they gave an indication of what they can do on five minutes as a good ball into the channel on the right side was collected and the guy planted the ball into the net. It was clearly offside, but served as a warning. That warning was quickly forgotten as we took the lead on nine minutes. Another ball out of their defence was intercepted, by Ramsay, and he played it on to Rankin-Costello, who in turn fed Kelman in the box. He still had a lot to do but pushed the ball wide of their keeper and managed from a tightish angle to find the net, avoiding a defender in the way.

That was no more than our start deserved. But we didn’t capitalise on it. Perhaps Norwich twigged what they needed to do to adjust to our set-up, perhaps we just took our foot off the gas. But from around 20 minutes they increasingly dominated possession and with their full-backs getting forward to good effect pushed Campbell and Grant back into defensive action. They took back the initiative and quite frankly seldom gave it back thereafter.

On 21 minutes it took a perfectly timed desperate last-ditch tackle by Koumetio to deny Norwich after their forward had got beyond both central defenders. Then a dangerous low cross that didn’t get converted. Increasingly out attacks were becoming sporadic and the result of long balls forward, one of which almost saw Kelman get in again. Grant was booked for a professional foul, then Edwards rather harshly for handball.

It wasn’t a great surprise that Norwich drew level, on 34 minutes. But it was a poor goal from our perspective. Ramsay did well to win the ball in the middle of the park, but unable to bring it under control ended up lobbing a ball back towards our goal, which nobody was anticipating. Their guy picked it up and with our back line pushed up picked the right pass, weighted just strong enough to wrongfoot Coventry, the last defender. Their guy took it into the box on the right side and from a narrow angle powered a shot above and beyond Okonkwu into the far corner of the net.

The rest of the half was played out with Norwich generally having the ball but not doing much with it, other than a shot over the bar from a reasonable position. The stats at the break showed they had 68% possession and had mustered six attempts on goal, one on target, against our four and two. So the game was still very much up for grabs, up to which team would take the initiative.

It proved to be Norwich, who came out of the traps like we had done at the start of the game. There was a credible claim for a penalty shortly after the restart as Coventry made a challenge and didn’t appear to get the ball, but nothing was given. A minute later Norwich broke and the full-back got forward, played it on down the right. The squared ball should have been converted, but fortunately for us the guy sliced wide.

It was a temporary reprieve as Norwich did take the lead on 49 minutes, another horrible goal from our perspective. We seemed to have won the ball outside our box but then lost it, allowing it to be played out to the left side. Nobody closed down the guy about to cross and inside the box it was chaos. Jones seemed to be drawn towards the near post, leaving Koumetio to cover the central forward. Only problem was behind him was all the space in the world for two Norwich players to get to the ball played in, with Edwards not sensing the danger. One of them headed in with Okonkwu getting a hand to the ball but not keeping it out.

We seemed to react well, Carey picking up a loose ball and driving into the box, his cross turned behind for a corner. It was his last contribution as he, along with Grant and Edwards, were replaced by Leaburn, Knibbs and Mesik. Looked like a switch to a 4-4-2, with Campbell on the right. And TC almost created an equaliser as he cut in on the left after the corner and his decent shot took a deflection that might have gone anywhere, just didn’t quite find the net.

It didn’t seem to matter as the corner was swung into the middle as was met firmly by the head of their defender and flew into the net. Everyone celebrated, Norwich seemed to accept their fate, then attention turned to a linesman with his flag raised. To total surprise he seemed to be indicating that Kelman was offside as the corner was played in. The replays showed that it was possible that his boot may have been, just possibly. It was the sort of one where if VAR had intervened there would have been howls about undue interference. Nobody would have looked twice at the possibility if the linesman had given nothing. He was probably the only man in the ground to believe the goal should have been ruled out, but technically he may have been correct.

We continued to make things happen and on 62 minutes TC broke on the right and played a ball in for Kelman. He took a touch to the side of their keeper but he reacted quickly enough and blocked the effort. On 74 minutes Mwamba came on for Coventry and by now it was all getting rather stretched. And we paid the price on 75 minutes as their guy broke down their right, bamboozled Koumetio around the byline and got in a low cross, which Mesik got a decisive touch to, sending it over Okonkwu and in for an own goal which did count.

After that we might have got one back, Norwich could well have added to their total. Mbick came on for Rankin-Costello, with no real formation after that, just hope that Norwich wouldn’t take advantage of the space left. Knibbs should have done better with a ball in from Campbell but failed to connect well, while Okonkwu made a couple of good saves in stoppage time to keep the scoreline down.

Two abiding questions for me at the end. First, how did we turn from the vibrant side which started the game and dominated the first 20 minutes, taking the lead, into the defence-minded, cautious team which we became – with the exception of the period after we went 1-2 down and before it became 1-3. Sure, Norwich would have worked things out, but we allowed Grant and Campbell to get pressed back into defensive duty and gave away possession too easily. Second, why are we defending so poorly. All three goals were poor from our perspective and none of the back line emerged with credit. We conceded two goals in the first three games of the season but 16 in the nine games since then. You don’t win much if anything if you are letting in two a game.

More generally, this is now officially a crisis. Watford and especially Norwich may be better than their form and league position going into games against us suggested, but they were both there for the taking and we failed to take advantage. If we can’t beat them, where does the next win come from? Fortunately we were in a poor run of form last season when we went away to Middlesbrough, parked the bus, saw little of the ball, but won thanks to a Coady conversion of a long throw. You’d get good odds on a similar result next Saturday (and unlike last season I’m not prepared to eat cheese if we win, we aren’t that desperate yet).

It is back to the training ground and work on defence in particular. What he does in terms of fresh changes, in personnel or formation, I’ve no idea. I thought it was taking a risk to start with Ramsay and Edwards as the full-backs, given they are both returning after injury, although also Jones and Koumetio were well short of their best today. It’s going to take a lot of figuring out.

 

Sunday, 18 October 2026

Post-Match Thoughts On Formations & Players

Nobody’s going to disagree with Nathan Jones’ post-match comments, including “it was as poor as we’ve been”. He, his staff, and the players have a week on the training ground to get things sorted, but is there anything useful that the rest of us can contribute, while acknowledging that the decisions and outcomes will be down to those who know vastly more about football than we do? No harm in trying.

First, the formation. Just why have we switched to a back five as the first choice option? For me there are only two reasons to play a back three/five with wing-backs. One, that you have real wing-backs available, players capable of getting up and down quickly and be comfortable both attacking and defending. Two, that you are up against it and want to park the bus. Sometimes that’s better done with a 4-4-2 but that’s another matter. I’d suggest that the former does not apply in our current situation and there was no good reason to go for the latter at Burnley or Watford.

Last season we struggled to secure a pair of proper wing-backs to play the formation. Experiments with Campbell and Apter were a (predictable) failure, Bree was able to play the part but he was recalled, Edwards worked well with TC in front of him going wide, but he got crocked. We ended up bringing in Clarke and Chambers in the January window, adding Fevrier (a true wing-back who I liked) for good measure. At the end of the season we allowed all three to return to their clubs, signed McNamara, a genuine full-back, all of which pointed to us being happy to switch to a back four.

It should have no effect, but I can’t help wondering if the sudden return from injury of defenders – Ramsay, Koumetio and Edwards – has influenced thinking. It has resulted in us, even without Burke and the unfortunate Sichenje, able to choose four or five from McNamara, Ramsay, Jones, Koumetio, Bindon, Bell, Edwards and Mesik. A back four and you have to choose between McNamara and Ramsay (or Mesik too), Koumetio and Bindon, and one from Bell, Edwards and Mesik, given that Jones is a nailed-on starter. I don’t see anything wrong with that, having good cover for each position.

Last season we played 3-5-2 (or 5-3-2 if you prefer). This time around we’ve gone to 5-2-3. And I don’t understand this either. Coventry and Skipp are coming in for a good deal of criticism, but the fact is that with 5-2-3 they are getting outnumbered when teams break forward in numbers and in possession they are quickly pressurised. Cardiff, Stoke and now Watford did that, steamrollering the defensive midfield and exploiting a poorly organised back line, in particular the spaces between the wing-backs and central defenders. That shouldn’t happen but is, with a confused look about us.

The fact is (IMO of course) that if you play with wing-backs, even though you don’t have the players for the formation, the last thing you want is a front three when two of the three expect to do their best work out wide. Against Watford Mesik was doing the wing-back role, getting forward to good effect, but that squeezed the space that Campbell would normally expect to move into. As a result not once did we see TC out wide with the ball at his feet looking to take on the defence, which has been our most potent attacking threat this season. Just the once, when moved to right-side wing-back, was he able to take on and beat for pace his opposite number.

As for the defensive midfield two, there has been disruption. Chalobah was excellent before his injury. That left Coventry, Ouma, Mwamba and then Skipp was added as Docherty (and Coady) were rejected. Ouma has looked accident-prone and there is speculation that we are looking to terminate his loan early. Mwamba is clearly a prospect, Skipp is no mean player. But the two in the formation in front of defence are not able to provide any coherent link to a front three. The play out from the back is too slow to utilise the wing-backs, especially when they are natural defenders.

In short, I find the return to a back three/five to not suit the players we have and to greatly reduce attacking options. Wing-backs who are really defenders, two in front of the defence getting overrun in and out of possession, and an isolated front three with little service and no space to operate in. Going to a back five and sticking with two in central midfield has (IMO) compounded the problem. Last season we had three, albeit with one (Carey) playing a more advanced role. Add into that mix a main centre-forward who currently can’t buy a goal – the headed chances against Burnley and Watford should have gone in – and you have, quite frankly, an impotent mess.

We started the season assuming as forward options, once Dykes opted to go somewhere else, Leaburn and Mbick as the big guys, Kelman and Godden as the goalscorers. Kelman got injured and is only just coming back, Godden is still out injured, and Mbick looks like a player asked to play at a higher level on his return from a long-term injury. Leaburn has done all that could be asked of him largely on his own, except put the ball in the net. There’s no easy answer to all this, except perhaps to go back to three behind the front man and bear the main responsibility for creating and putting away chances, as Grant did when fed by TC against Bristol City.

Let’s not pretend that the 4-2-3-1 we started the season with has worked like a dream. We won the first three thanks to coming from behind at home to Derby, eeking out a one-goal win at home to Preston (two teams which have struggled so far this season), and had one magnificent backs-to-the-wall victory, at West Ham, helped by an overhead goal from a centre-back and a last-minute missed penalty. We struggled to link up play and in particular to find the right guy to play in the middle of the more forward three. We understandably started with Carey, but the role places an emphasis on coordinating play between the three, picking the right passes, rather than powering forward on your own. We tried Grant in the central role but that didn’t work. Jones has been reluctant to try either Knibbs or Rankin-Costello in the role. Perhaps it is now time to try (with Carey ready from the bench depending on the state of the game). One cliché is that the fastest eight individually do not always produce the fastest boat. If Knibbs is viewed as too lightweight then go for Rankin-Costello.

Another cliché is that every good team knows its strengths and plays to them. Right now we have lost sight of our strengths. Grinding out clean sheets served us well last season but I don’t think the answer right now is to pack the defence. Burnley scored twice with goals from around the edge of the area, Watford could have scored far more than two.

So my advice, for what it is worth, is abandon the back three/five. We don’t have the wing-backs to make it work. If we stick with a back three/five, we need to have a midfield three, not two, they are getting overrun. If we go with 5-3-2 bite the bullet and accept that it means no place for Campbell or Grant, with Carey brought back to a more natural role as he played last season (if his confidence has not been shot). Alternatively, go for the 4-2-3-1 with either Knibbs or Rankin-Costello in the centre of the three. Whether Leaburn needs a rest and whether Mbick or Kelman might start instead is another one for Jones and his team to look at and decide.

Added to all of this, we do need every player to play their hearts out against Norwich (and beyond of course). A week to get ready, no excuses.

 

Saturday, 17 October 2026

Dispiriting Defeat

A six-day jolly around the UK (Givry-London, London-Whitehaven, Whitehaven-Burnley, Burnley-London, London-Givry) meant I was able to be at The Valley for the Bristol City game and at Turf Moor for the midweek clash with Burnley. Both games had pluses and minuses, both could have gone either way, but ultimately they meant two more added to the list of games without a win. That set up today’s game, against opponents seemingly on the ropes and probably low on confidence. This had all the hallmarks of one we needed to win, to stop the run, to show the ruthlessness necessary to thrive in this division.

Win? We came away beaten and our tails very much between our legs after a performance right out of the worst of last season. Played ugly and lost, to a team which didn’t match our expectations – although we seldom pressured them sufficiently to find out why they have conceded so many of late. They had a game-plan and stuck to it, breaking quickly and with numbers. We degenerated into a mess with curious substitutions and if Watford could shoot straight would have lost by more.

Ahead of the game there was uncertainty about the team/squad Jones would select, driven not least by whether we would revert to the 4-2-3-1 system or go with five at the back as against Burnley. It proved to be the latter, with Mesik rewarded for his glorious last-gasp strike with a start in place of Bell, with McNamara the right-side wing back and Ramsay, Jones and Koumetio the central three. Coventry and Skipp would be the midfield pair and Campbell, Leaburn and Grant as a kind of front three. So pretty much as you were, with the formation leaving a defensive bias and Knibbs, Carey and Rankin-Costello (he not in the squad) to bide their time, while Kelman and Mbick, plus Alli out wide, were the options from the bench.

We began the game sloppily, poor passes and miscontrol giving away possession and encouraging Watford. Rather out of the blue we almost took the lead on eight minutes. Moving out of defence Koumetio created space and played the ball wide for Mesik. He delivered an excellent cross to find Leaburn in space. But he finished like someone very low on confidence in front of goal, heading wide when he really should have scored. How different the game may have turned out if he had.

That moment was the exception to the rule in the first half as we allowed a succession of Watford chances and ended with McNamara, Skipp and Campbell all on yellow cards (followed early in the second half by Coventry), Skipp going on to test the ref’s patience with further fouls. On 14 minutes the shot from another player cutting inside drew a good save from Okonkwo; on 21 Ramsay misjudged a ball forward only for their guy to shoot wastefully wide from a good position; on 26 minutes it took a perfectly timed flying challenge from Koumetio to prevent what looked a probable goal; and on 29 a simple one-two put another Watford player in, his effort saved by Okonkwo.

We did get more of a foothold in the game later in the half, with a scuffed effort from Campbell after a corner was headed out turned only just wide by Koumetio; and on 46 minutes Campbell might have done better when let in by a Watford mistake. But at the break you felt that Watford had nullified our threat with their 5-3-2 formation, with Campbell and Grant barely in the game, and made use of their extra man in central midfield to create more openings. The stats at the break showed they had 53% possession with eight efforts on goal, three on target, against five and one for us. Bottom line was we had to play better.

Jones kept the formation unchanged for the start of the second half, but replaced Skipp with Mwamba, with a possible red card for the former probably in his mind. The game continued in a similar fashion, although we did have another chance to take the lead. On 53 minutes Leaburn got the better of his marker on the right and took the ball on. His low cross was delivered just behind the incoming Grant, who was unable to control the ball and put it away. And in the next minute it was almost Watford as a break saw them with three on two. The guy was played in on goal but put his shot wide. It proved to be a temporary reprieve as Watford did finally score on 57 minutes. One of theirs was allowed to advance unchallenged into the box. His shot was parried by Okonkwu but only into the path of their forward who scored.

Going behind sparked a triple substitution by Jones on 61 minutes with Knibbs, Carey and Kelman replacing McNamara, Coventry and Grant. We kept to the three/five at the back but with Campbell moving to right wing-back, while Kelman joined Leaburn up front and we were left with a midfield three of Knibbs, Carey and Mwamba. Basically both defensive midfielders had been replaced – and it showed.

Watford dropped deeper but continued to pose a threat on the break. From our free kick on 68 minutes (after Jones was clearly elbowed in the face, one which VAR would have had a good look at) they went up the other end. Okonkwo blocked the first effort and another put the rebound over the bar. We huffed and puffed and created a scramble or two, most notably on 78 minutes as Alli, who had replaced Campbell, was pulled back and the resulting free-kick went in to the mix. Ramsay almost got on the end of it, finally Kelman did, but his effort from close range was blocked by their keeper on the line and then cleared.

On 81 minutes it took a late challenge by Ramsay to prevent Watford scoring again, then Okonkwo made an excellent save from a flicked header at the near post from a corner. On 84 minutes Watford missed another, while our afternoon was summed up by a horrible Carey shot. In five minutes of stoppage time Mwamba picked up a yellow and then Watford finally finished things off as a pass inside caught us out and their guy chipped Okonkwo to put, for them, the icing very much on the cake.

It was a depressing afternoon. We chose what was in essence a defensive formation (as at Burnley as McNamara and Bell/Mesik are not natural wing-backs, although Mesik did get forward well), supposedly keeping things tight, against opponents we thought would be worse than they proved to be (but hardly worldbeaters). We failed to impose ourselves on the game and were caught on the break by passing and movement so often it was embarrassing. We needed to score first but didn’t take the best chance of the first-half, or another early in the second. Then having gone behind we made changes which left us even more open – and confused me at least. Who thought that bringing on both Knibbs and Carey would work (one or the other would have done)? And Campbell as right-side wing-back?

The only positive for me was another excellent display by Koumetio. Jones will have a lot of thinking to do before Norwich come visiting next Saturday. Top of the list is surely that playing with wing-backs and having a sort of front three with Campbell and Grant stymied for space is not playing to our strengths. Not once today did TC have the ball at his feet on the left wing while Leaburn's lack of a goal is looking increasingly a burden. Why have we reverted to five at the back from the start? Is it the result of suddenly having more defenders back and available (such that some have to be dropped)? We badly miss Chalobah back fit to partner Coventry. All is not well and needs sorting out before this becomes an outright crisis.

 

Defeat And Focus Quickly On Tuesday Night

The vital win ahead of the international break seemed to take a little of the pressure off this one. Of course we wanted something out of th...